• Dr. Riaz Ahmad Saeed Department of Islamic Studies, National University of Modern Languages, Islamabad,
  • Ms Salma Razzaq PhD Scholar, NUML, Islamabad.


This study elaborates western concept of freedom of expression and speech and carries out analysis in the light of Islamic perspective in modern Islamic socio-political context. The Western thought recognizes freedom of speech as a key value to human rights and civil liberties. They also have different standards of application in limiting or delimiting the freedom of speech and expression. The West perceives that Freedom of expression is the first and last trench in the protection of other liberties and rights by governance based on Secularism. Islam also preserves and protects the right of freedom of expression and speech but within some moral, legal and social norms in the interest of society. This is the basic difference between Islamic and Western understanding of freedom of expression. It is being witnessed that the western concept of freedom of expression is fast creeping into Muslim societies in the garb of misinterpretation of the Islamic principles of freedom, thus we need to understand the Western thought on freedom to counter it through Islamic concept to avoid its negative impact on Muslim societies. Descriptive and analytical approaches have been adopted in this study with qualitative research methodology.


The New Zealand Bill of Rights Act; The New Zealand Bill of Rights Act (NZBORA)1990 gives a supreme status to New Zealand’s Parliament defines the fundamental rights and liberties subject to laws.

. Moreham Nicole, “Hosking v Runting and the Protection of Privacy”, The New Zealand Law Journal 12:2 (2006):265-267http://heinonline.org/HOL/LandingPage?handle=hein.journals/newzlndlr2006&div.

. Gordon Carruth (ed.), The Encyclopedia, (Chicago: Filed Educational Co., 1952), 7:428.

. Leon L. Bram (ed.), Funk and Wagnall’s Encyclopedia (New York: Funk & Wagnall, 1985), 24:262.

. Campbell, Black’s Law Dictionary, 1065.

. Cartwright Will, “Mill on Freedom of Discussion”, Richmond Journal of Philosophy 15:4 (2003):1-7; www.richmond-philosophy.net/rjp/back_issues/rjp5_cartwright.pdf.

. Cayenne, The Encyclopedia Americana, 17:303.

. Pall, The Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 3:223.

. Robert A. Dutch (ed.), The Original Roget’s Thesaurus of English Words and Phrases (New York: Longman Publishers Inc., 1982), 1:408.

. Gunn T. Jeremy, “The Complexity of Religion and the Definition of Religion in International Law”, Harvard Human Rights Journal (2003), Vol.16, PP.190-215; www.peacepalacelibrary.nl/plinklet/index.php?ppn=326687351.

. https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/freedom-toolkit.pdf/Accessed: 8/1/2018.

. Gordon, The Encyclopedia, 7:431.

. Edward Lawson (ed.), Encyclopedia of Human Rights (Washington: Taylor & Frances, 1996), 372.

. ECHR: It stands for European Convention of Human Rights. It is an important western document of human rights. It is considered the most vital document of rights and freedom after the UDHR, in the world.

. Jim Murdoch, Freedom of Thought, A Guideline to the Article 9 (Strasburg: ECHR, 2007), 8.

. Murdoch, A Guideline to the Article 9, 2: 9.

. McGraw, New Catholic Encyclopedia, 6:107.

. Scanlon, Thomas, “A Theory of Freedom of Expression”, Philosophy and Public Affairs 1:2 (1972):204-226; http://www.harvard-jlpp.com/vols-30-34/#343.

. Archibald Cox, Freedom of Expression (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1981), 1.

. J B Bury, A History of Freedom of Thought (New York: Henry Holt & Company, 1913), 7.

. Jean-François Renucci, Article 9 of the European Convention of Human Rights,Freedom of Thought, Conscience and Religion (Strasburg: Council of Europe Publishing, 2005), 6.

. Castagno, The Encyclopedia Americana, 25:473.

. Christina Holtz, “What is “Good” Press Freedom?”Journal of IAMCR 25:30(2004):1-15; www.kowi.wiso.uni-erlangen.de/publikationen/press freedom.

. BayoOloyede, “Press Freedom: A Conceptual Analyses”, Journal of Social Sciences 11:2(2005):101-109.

. Mathew W Finkin, and Robert G Post, For the Common Good (London: Yale University Press, 2009), 11.

. Sills, The Encyclopedia of Social Sciences, 3:599.

. Ben Clark,” Freedom of Speech and Criticism of Religion; what are the limits?” Murdoch University E-Law Journal (2007), Vol.14, No.2, PP.94-121;http://ssrn.com/abstract=1716558.

. Mathew and Robert, For the Common Good, 11.

. Howard Cincotta, Democracy in brief, Bauru of International Information Programs (Washington: Department of State, USA, 2007),3.

. Kam?l?, The Dignity of Man, 9.

. Muslim, Im?m Muslim bin ?ajj?j al-Qushayr?, ?a??? Muslim (Riyadh: Darussalam, 2007), Hadith no.46.

. Al-Qura’an 2:82

. SahihMuslim hadith no. :69

. Al-Quran 22:30

. Ibn?ambal, A?mad, Im?m, Musnad al-Im?mA?mad bin ?ambal(Beir?t: Muassisah al-Ris?lah, 2001), Hadith no. 19774

. Bukh?r?, MuhammadbinIsmail. Al-?a??? al- J?mi (Beirut: D?rTawq al-Nij?h, 1422 AH(, Hadith no. 6922



How to Cite

Dr. Riaz Ahmad Saeed, & Ms Salma Razzaq. (2021). WESTERN CONCEPT OF FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION (AN ANALYSIS IN ISLAMIC CONTEXT). Zia E Tahqeeq, 10(20), 81-97. Retrieved from //ziaetahqeeq.gcuf.edu.pk/index.php/ziaetahqeeq/article/view/16